The nitty-gritty of solitary confinement

    Captive

    The high walls of prison complexes don’t just keep prisoners in; they keep the public out. That’s nowhere more true than in long-term solitary confinement – prisons within prisons – where people can spend years alone and forgotten.

    The ACLU, Human Rights Watch, and Rights For Imprisoned People with Psychiatric Disabilities, have long organized against solitary confinement, often euphemized by administrators as “segregation” or “the special housing unit” but known to prisoners as “the box” or “the hole.” Thanks to one ACLU lawsuit, it is now illegal in Indiana to keep mentally ill prisoners in extreme isolation.

    Atul Gawande called long-term solitary confinement nothing short of torture in a powerful New Yorker article, “Hellhole.” I sought to add to Gawande’s account by describing ordinary life in solitary confinement. I interviewed Ohio inmate Sean Swain who’s had “seven or eight” stints in “solitary confinement since 1991, as well as Shirley Pope, director of Ohio’s Correctional Institution Inspection Committee (CIIC), authorized by the state legislature to inspect prisons.

    In Ohio in 2007, approximately 1 in 25 prisoners lived in isolation at any one time. It’s not known how many people live in isolation at some point during their sentence. Some 25,000 U.S. prisoners are isolated at “supermax prisons,” with another 50-80,000 at other prisons, according to Gawande’s article.

    Swain detailed the conditions: Insects swarmed around lighting fixtures. Tube-lighting was never shut off.  Soap and toilet paper were sometimes lacking. Prisoners used bedsheets as towels. And as the CIIC confirmed, prisons have begun to double-bunk solitary cells due to overcrowding. Prisoners can now spend 23 hours a day with another person, in a cell designed for single occupancy.

    The article also looks at why the mentally ill end up in isolation, “in spite of the known mental-health deterioration stemming from long-term isolation.” As one expert explained to me, “Their behavior is destined to deteriorate under those conditions. Then their poor behavior is used to justify why they should be there.”

    Read the article at the International Network of Street Newspapers. It appeared in Cincinnati’s Streetvibes, published by the local Coalition for the Homeless.

    Image: “Captive” by Todd Tarselli, American Journal of Public Health.



    Recent Stories

    • Analysis

    How undocumented immigrants won driver’s licenses in Massachusetts

    September 30, 2022

    After years of struggle, immigrants built a formidable coalition and collaborated on dozens of actions with Jews to win a key victory in Massachusetts.

    • Breaking News

    Alabama prison strike over ‘neo slavery’ conditions continues amid claims of severe crackdown

    September 29, 2022

    Thousands of incarcerated workers in Alabama are on strike to protest forced unpaid labor, as they face alleged retaliation from prison officials.

    • Analysis

    The rights of nature movement cannot be stopped

    September 27, 2022

    From the Navajo Nation to a small town in Pennsylvania to Ecuador, then across the world, the idea of enshrining the rights of nature is only growing.