• Follow @wagingnv
'Popular coup' ousts Egypt's president
  • Support WNV
  • About
    • Home
    • Conflict
      • Conflict resolution
      • Tactics
      • Theory
      • Training and organizing
    • Culture
      • Art
      • History
      • Media
      • Religion
      • Sports
      • Technology
    • Regions
      • Africa
      • Asia
      • Europe
      • Latin America
      • North America
      • Oceania and Pacific islands
    • Issues
      • Economic justice
      • Environment
      • Human Rights
      • Militarism
    • Series
      • Beautiful Trouble
      • Beyond Borders
      • #IdleNoMore
      • Sans Tar Sands
      • Wildcat Winter
    • Columns
      • At the Crossroads
      • Little Insurrections
      • Living Revolution
    • Blog
    • Experiments
  • Revolution 2.0 in Egypt

    Original article at https://wagingnonviolence.org/feature/popular-coup-ousts-egypts-president/

    Images Shown. Click to Hide Images

    • Laura Gottesdiener
    • July 3, 2013
    • Email
    • Print
    • Leave a Tip

    Share This Article

    Fireworks burst over crowds dancing and waving flags in Cairo's Tahrir Square after news of President Morsi's ouster. (Flickr / samataa)

    Fireworks burst over crowds dancing and waving flags in Cairo’s Tahrir Square after news of President Morsi’s ouster. (Flickr / samataa)

    On Wednesday, Egypt’s President Mohammed Morsi was overthrown by millions of protesters and the Egyptian armed forces in what many are calling a “relaunch” of the 2011 Egyptian revolution.

    Amidst widespread protests and celebrations across the nation this evening, Egypt’s top military general announced that the constitution has been suspended and that the head of the Supreme Constitutional Court will act as interim president until the early elections.

    The international community and media are now divided over whether the ousting of Morsi constitutes a military coup d’etat. According to U.S. international law, aid cannot be given to any nation where the democratically elected president has been deposed, meaning Egypt could lose out on $1.3 billion in foreign aid.

    Nevertheless, the protests against Morsi and his political party, the Muslim Brotherhood, have intensified quickly over the last week. Millions of people mobilized and occupied squares across the nation on Sunday, prompting the armed forces to give Morsi a 48-hour ultimatum to leave office. In a nod to the humor of the Egyptian movement, some activists created a “Bye Bye Morsi” countdown ticker, while another activist created a QR code sign that calls for Morsi’s departure in 14 different languages.

    The current opposition movement began with a grassroots campaign called Tamarod, which means rebel in Arabic. Founded in late April, the movement’s participants spent months collecting signatures for a petition that denounced the lack of physical and economic security since Morsi assumed office. Using both social media and traffic-blocking sign-ins, the activists said they collected more than 22 million signatures as of this week, a full quarter of Egypt’s population.

    The future role of the military — which ruled the nation for the second half of the 20th century — will be a major factor in determining the outcome of this week’s events. Currently, the armed forces and the opposition movements appear to have an alliance, one perhaps prompted by fear of Egypt devolving into a violent situation similar to Syria. On Monday, the spokesperson of the Tamarod movement backed the military’s 48-hour ultimatum, saying, “the army responding to the demands of the people crowns our movement.” Wednesday, the spokesman rejected the idea of a military coup, calling it instead a “popular coup.”

    Although the idea of a “popular coup” appears counterintuitive, it is not impossible. In a 2012 essay in the Harvard International Law Journal, law professor Ozan Varol argues for the potential of a “democratic coup d’etat” — essentially an upheaval that falls within the confines of democracy rather than outside it. According to Varol, there are seven determining factors:

    “The military coup is staged against an authoritarian or totalitarian regime; the military responds to popular opposition against that regime; the authoritarian or totalitarian leader refuses to step down in response to the popular opposition; the coup is staged by a military that is highly respected within the nation, ordinarily because of mandatory conscription; the military executes the coup to overthrow the authoritarian or totalitarian regime; the military facilitates free and fair elections within a short span of time; and the coup ends with the transfer of power to democratically elected leaders.”

    Interestingly, one of the democratic coup d’etats that Varol highlighted was the 2011 Egyptian revolution.

    Whether this week’s events in Egypt would qualify as a democratic coup d’etat depends on when the military holds the promised elections and transfers power to elected leaders, as well as whether one considers Morsi’s presidency an “authoritarian or totalitarian regime.” After the 2011 revolution, the military remained in control of the country for far longer than many Egyptians wanted, and social media is already filled with statements by activists rejecting the possibility of sustained military rule. As Egyptian activist Mayssa Sultan wrote on Facebook:

    “We are not interested in returning to military rule.[We] will not be duped again to celebrating in the streets until we have a civilian Presidential council in place, a new plan for developing an honest and open dialogue which creates a Constitution which is just, includes all members and segments of society and a process for transitioning to the system of government we were going for in the first place. This is a chance to re-live February 11, 2011, when we celebrated, went home and waited for justice to occur.”

    Since taking office 13 months ago, Morsi’s presidency has been riddled with economic, political, social and religious problems. As food prices rose and gas shortages became common, Morsi came under intense criticism for annulling constitutional amendments and attempting to give himself the right to legislate without judicial oversight. He also began targeting and jailing comedians and journalists. Yet, the tipping point — at least in Morsi’s relationship to the military — may have come last month when he attended a rally with Islamic radicals calling for a “holy war” in Syria.

    These criticisms sparked the current protests, which many are heralding as a continuation of the Arab Spring uprising. Yet, increasingly, this week’s mobilizations are manifesting some of the same challenges as two years ago — particularly around sexual violence in occupied spaces. According to the group Operation Anti-Sexual Harassment/Assault, there were nearly 50 sexual assaults during protests on June 30 alone. According to many activists, the Muslim Brotherhood is using sexual assault and rape to undermine the protests and deter women from participating. But activists also contend that the sexual violence is coming from within the movement itself. As one Egyptian activist explained on Facebook:

    “When assaults happened on last January 25th, there was a campaign by civilian, leftist and nationalist parties alongside the media crying out that the Muslim Brotherhood want to terrorize women and are using the old regime’s tactics by organized mobs. That was the end of it. Many of us tried to explain to ‘our camp’ that the issue is larger than organized mobs and that harassment is a common daily occurrence everywhere; that everyday papers have news of rape incidents; and that it even happen during feasts. They all dealt with us as we are mad.”

    Nevertheless, protesters have learned from the Arab Spring mobilizations, and activists groups like the Tahrir Bodyguards are already organized and working to combat sexual harassment and violence in mass mobilizations.

    Outside the increasing problem of sexual violence and a handful of clashes between pro- and anti-Morsi activists, the transition has largely been nonviolent. Today, however, the military has sent armored vehicles to the sites of pro-Morsi rallies, issued arrest warrants for 300 members of the Muslim Brotherhood and is reportedly planning to clear these gatherings. Security forces even raided Al Jazeera’s Egypt service (Al Jazeera Misr), detaining staff members and stopping the broadcast from a pro-Morsi rally.

    Such actions highlight the precarious and potentially problematic role of the military in the coming days. Unlike in other countries, Egypt’s military has a stake in almost every industry in the country, raising further questions as to the institution’s motivation for involvement.

    Despite these outstanding questions, many are celebrating the events as evidence that the Arab Spring succeeded in radicalizing Egyptian society, re-instilling the population with the spirit of protest.

    “They thought good enough was enough,” wrote Mayssa Sultan on Wednesday. “We said, no, we want it all.”

    —

    This story was made possible by our members. Become one today.

    Help Us Spread The Word

    • Email
    • Print
    • Leave a Tip

    Share This Article

    • Topics:
    • Militarism
    • Protests
    • Democracy
    • Media
    • Economic justice
    • Egypt

    Laura Gottesdiener is a freelance journalist in New York City. She is the author of A Dream Foreclosed: Black America and the Fight for a Place to Call Home, forthcoming from Zuccotti Park Press.

    Pick-ups

    Common Dreams

    Related

    4 comments

    1. Nathan Schneider
      July 4, 2013 at 4:15 pm

      I wish I understood better the reasons for the Egyptian military’s popularity. Last time it took power, there had to be massive protests as well to force it to allow the constitutional process to move forward. From what I’ve been told, the military museum in Egypt is full of factual inaccuracies about the military’s supposed victories in various conflicts. It’s well known that the United States holds a controlling stake in Egypt’s military thanks to billions of dollars in money and arms. What is it, exactly, that makes this military so trustworthy for so many people?

      One wonders what kind of coup might take place if the military weren’t so powerful and able to sweep in and take control at any moment. What other kinds of democratic coups are possible?

      • ARTH
        July 5, 2013 at 1:33 pm

        The situation under Military rule, i.e. Mubarak was substantially better although who could have imagined that at the time…

    2. SaM Deedes
      July 10, 2013 at 9:56 pm

      This is dangerous stuff. Illusions in the concept of a good coup are wrong headed.

      The Egyptian army only ever acted in the interests of shoring up its entrenched privileges.

      I have no brief for Morsi, but incompetence is not a crime and he cannot be accused of criminal activity, the only real justification for forcible removal.

      We have already seen many killings by the Egyptian army since this piece was written, highlighting the inevitability of blood being spilt whenever there is a coup.

      The blood is not always spilt at the time of the coup either. Many people here in Thailand praised the nonviolence of the 2006 army coup. They changed their tune when its effects were played out in the streets of Bangkok with 90 killed by the army in 2010.

    3. JAMes warren
      July 11, 2013 at 6:26 pm

      This is the sort of necessary narrative the global culture needs to be paying attention to and supporting. No one else is going to reframe the world’s conflicts in honest and positive terms.

    Top Headlines

    How to fight fascism from a position of strength
    Revisiting the Catonsville Nine’s greatest day
    Temple controversy sparks quiet revolution by women for religious equality in India

    Most Commented

    Revisiting the Catonsville Nine’s greatest day
    3 Comments
    How can allies protect communities threatened with violence?
    2 Comments
    Temple controversy sparks quiet revolution by women for religious equality in India
    0 Comments

    More By Laura Gottesdiener

    The Laundry Workers Center strikes again
    On Women’s Day, fight violence, both institutional and intimate
    In defense of apartment dinners

    Blog

    Why activists shouldn’t be afraid of polarizing an issue through protest

    Paul Engler and Sophie Lasoff
    January 23, 2019

    The Indigenous Peoples March was about a lot more than the kids in MAGA hats

    Tekendra Parmar
    January 21, 2019

    Why Americans need to act like the majority we already are

    Onnesha Roychoudhuri
    January 18, 2019

    To weaken Trump, target his enablers

    L.A. Kauffman
    January 17, 2019

    Actions across Latin America target the notorious School of the Americas

    Tom Power
    December 18, 2018

    #MeToo movement honored at Disobedience Award celebrating the power of women

    Barbara Peterson
    December 7, 2018
    • More Blog Posts

    Get Involved

    If you have an interest in promoting stories of nonviolence, building this community and correcting the mainstream media’s misrepresentation of nonviolent action, please consider donating to Waging Nonviolence.

    Donate

    If you’d like to develop a more ongoing supporting relationship with WNV, consider joining our membership program instead of making a one-time donation.

    Become a Member

    Columns

    WNV Column Little Insurrections
    Little Insurrections

    by Frida Berrigan

    WNV Column Living Revolution
    Living Revolution

    by George Lakey

    WNV Column The Arts of Protest
    The Arts of Protest

    by Nadine Bloch

    Image by Itzy Ramirez.

    Experiments with Truth

    News

    People across US gather to protest recent police shootings
     WNBA teams show what Black Lives Matter solidarity looks like
    Photo of woman being arrested in Baton Rouge becomes viral symbol
    Former guard launches hunger strike to protest private prison company
    Job boycott shuts down much of Zimbabwe as discontent grows
    Protests in London as seven-year Iraq Inquiry wait comes to end

    Analysis

    Why Black Lives Matter has gained momentum in Britain – a country where police shootings are rare
    What the media got wrong about the House sit-in for gun control
    From Black Power to Black Lives Matter
    Neil Young says there is no place to play protest songs today
    The value of protesting Bernie Sanders
    How could they?
    • More Experiments

    Series

    WNV Series Longform
    Longform

    In-depth storytelling that captures the universal human drama of people building power from the ground up.

    WNV Series We Are Many
    We Are Many

    A podcast about people working for change and how that work, in turn, changes them. Subscribe on iTunes, Stitcher, Tune In and PRX or by RSS.

    WNV Series Peace Science Digest
    Peace Science Digest

    The Peace Science Digest provides organized, accessible and relevant analysis of the top academic research in the field of peace and conflict studies.

    WNV Series Beyond Borders
    Beyond Borders

    Through provocative and courageous action, immigrants are challenging the very existence of the border.

    • Home
    • About
    • Support
    • Subscribe
    • Feed
    • Terms of Use
    • Contact

    Waging Nonviolence content falls under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

    Site designed and developed by Social Ink [+]