When I handcuffed my wrist to the White House fence on February 13 along with author Bill McKibben, the Sierra Club’s Michael Brune, civil rights icon Julian Bond and 44 others, it was a big moment for my organization, Earth Quaker Action Team. Here we were, only 3 years old, suddenly part of a high-profile act of civil disobedience in front of a throng of reporters. Strangely enough, it wasn’t even for the issue our group has been organizing against.
The story of our participation in the White House arrests, as well as the massive Forward on Climate rally four days later, is an example of how movements not only empower campaigns, but also how campaigns, in turn, empower movements.
Earth Quaker Action Team (or EQAT, pronounced “equate”) was founded by a small band of Philadelphia Quakers who wanted to use nonviolent direct action to work for a just and sustainable economy. Realizing the importance of having a campaign with a specific target, we chose to focus on PNC Bank’s financing of mountaintop removal coal mining. The Pennsylvania-based bank with Quaker roots was one of the top financiers of a practice that was causing increased rates of cancer and birth defects in Appalachia. Targeting PNC, which calls itself a “green bank,” was a strategic way to support embattled activists in Appalachia, who often feel forgotten by the wider environmental justice movement.
Although both the civil disobedience at the White House and the largest climate rally in U.S. history focused on the Keystone XL pipeline, we felt that participating in these events gave EQAT an opportunity to reframe our campaign after years of being asked why we weren’t working on fracking — the environmental justice issue that makes the most news in Pennsylvania. We explained to both the press and our supporters that as the easy-to-get to coal, oil and gas is used up, fossil fuel companies engage in increasingly destructive methods of getting more. Mountaintop removal, fracking and the tar sands oil that the pipeline is intended to transport are all part of the same big problem: poisoning the water of people who live near them, while prolonging our addiction to climate-change-causing fossil fuels.
The fact that I was arrested with nationally known figures like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and Darryl Hannah got us interviewed by the Philadelphia Inquirer and the local NPR affiliate, giving us the chance to explain both our campaign and this wider context. Despite some subsequent activist criticism that neither the White House action nor the rally was radical enough, participating in them also gave us unique opportunities to build both our organization and the wider movement.
In the past three years, our tactics have included civil disobedience, public account closings and a 200-mile walk across Pennsylvania to PNC’s national headquarters in Pittsburgh. Our last day of action on December 1 hit 15 PNC branches in five states and the District of Columbia, but we know that is not enough to change the fifth largest bank in the United States. We want our footprint to be as wide as PNC’s.
In the past three years, we have made many people curious about our edgy style, but we wanted to move those folks from curiosity to involvement. Organizing six buses for the national rally gave us the chance to identify people who were longing to do more than press “like” on Facebook and offered them a first step that was fun and safe. Tapping the enthusiasm the rally was generating, we mobilized other people of faith, environmentalists, college students and Quakers who hadn’t joined us before. We got their email addresses and showed a video on each bus that explained EQAT’s campaign. By the end of the day, we had interested a whole new group of people in getting involved with us — some of whom don’t identify as activists. I gave a ride home to one such woman from my husband’s church who had never been to a national rally before and, despite sore hips and cold fingers, seemed energized by the experience.
George Lakey, one of EQAT’s founders and a columnist for Waging Nonviolence, argues that being able to reach people who don’t think of themselves as activists is one of the main reasons to organize for a national march. “When we talk about the threat, we tend to make it very large — the fossil fuel industry — and we are very small,” he said. “We need to have the experience of being the many.” Only when people see that our support is proportionate to the size of the problem will they want to join us. “Small groups need to affiliate with larger actions in order to build our own credibility about being part of a movement large enough to tackle larger problems,” he added, while noting that it is always a matter of balance to decide what to mobilize for and how often.
For EQAT, one test is that the groups we affiliate with are trying to use nonviolent direct action techniques strategically to escalate pressure on powerful institutions. If Sunday’s march had just been a bunch of people walking around the White House and then going home, we wouldn’t have gone to the trouble of turning out six buses. What made it more than that in our eyes was the fact that 350.org had already used civil disobedience successfully — helping to delay the pipeline in 2011 — which means that when they bring over 40,000 people to the White House there is an implied threat, even if the rhetoric of the day was tame.
We were also excited by the early rumors we’d heard that there would be civil disobedience and that it would include the Sierra Club. Although the arrests ended up happening four days before the rally — partly to ensure that there would be arrests since the police don’t like to cuff more than 50 protesters at a time — EQAT was encouraged to see the Sierra Club take this step for the first time. In terms of risk, it was hardly like the lunch counter sit-ins during the civil rights movement, but it was an escalation from the group’s previous policy. The challenge for these national groups, and for us, is to keep the movement growing and the tactics escalating, until we become a force that President Obama sees as more important than a golf outing with oil executives, which is where he was during the rally.
Finding the right degree of edginess to both grow and escalate simultaneously is a bit of a dance. As I waited for Park Police to cut off my plastic handcuffs, I talked to fellow arrestee Maria Gunnoe, from the Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition, about the brutality of police in Appalachia, where Big Coal controls the political establishment. Gunnoe has the guts to challenge the coal companies in her home state of West Virginia, which is braver than anything I’ve ever done. Yet many of my non-activist friends called me “brave” for getting arrested in front of jostling photographers. One said she was worried sick about me, even though I knew there was no real risk. This gap in perception is a reminder of how much work we have to do to mobilize ordinary people to show the kind of courage and commitment necessary to win against the fossil fuel companies.
That is a good example of why EQAT chose to take part in these national events. “We want to reassure average citizens that it’s okay to step out of their comfort zones and empower them to find the satisfaction that comes with taking meaningful action,” said Amy Ward Brimmer, EQAT’s executive director, who was waiting for me when I was released from the Anacostia Park Police station a few hours after my arrest.
It is EQAT’s hope that we will model the passion and possibility that enable people to act boldly and locally, while giving them the reassuring feeling of being one of the many.
This collection of stories from the WNV archive offers inspiration, tools and other resources for those working to end police violence in the wake of George Floyd’s murder.
The coronavirus pandemic has made brilliant Iraqi occupation literature relatable for the first time to a wider American public living in quarantine.
As activists weary from war, campus killings, a tyrant in the White House and poverty at home started dropping out, Movement for a New Society built a model of sustainability.